TURKEY: United Nations climate talks couldn't reach an overarching agreement on Sunday because of disagreements over whether to mention the fossil fuels that cause global warming.
Expectations had already been low heading into the two-week negotiations in Turkey, but impasses over explicitly including fossil fuels and other issues, including money, proved irreconcilable.
Though the talks, called COP31, failed to reach a main agreement known as a cover decision, the meeting had already made progress on smaller issues.
This all happened as global warming accelerates with ever-worsening heat waves, floods, storms and droughts. The UN said it is now inevitable that the world will soon blow past the warming threshold established by the 2015 Paris climate agreement. And there is also a global energy shock due to the war in Iran. On top of that, a strong El Niño amplifies human-caused warming and causes more weather disasters.
Any pact approved at the talks requires near-unanimous consensus. Several countries and the 27-nation European Union said they could not accept the final proposal from the joint Turkish-Australian leadership, which didn't mention fossil fuels. A considerably larger number of nations accepted the decision, often reluctantly, saying consensus on something was more important, though it ultimately failed. Russia and Saudi Arabia sought to keep fossil fuels out of the document.
“It's unconscionable that we would have a climate act that makes no reference to fossil fuels,” Darragh O'Brien, Ireland's climate minister, said on behalf of the EU at the climate talks, which were running nearly 48 hours overtime at the Turkish resort town of Antalya.
Previously, fossil fuels went unmentioned in COP final decisions for more than 25 years, said Alden Meyer, with the think tank E3G. Then, three years ago in the oil-rich United Arab Emirates, a groundbreaking agreement called for “transitioning away from fossil fuels” but since then there's been no explicit mention of fossil fuels. The Turkish-Australian proposal recalled the Dubai in its entirety, but that wasn't enough to many nations and environmental groups.
Adding to the disagreement was the fact that the draft included explicit language and a goal for carbon capture and storage for industrial polluters, which many nations and activists said would undermine efforts to reduce overall emissions.
“The failure of this COP to deliver ambitious, fair, science-based outcomes falls squarely on the shoulders of richer nations, petrostates, and the disgracefully incompetent duo of the Turkish and Australian COP presidents,” said Rachel Cleetus of the Union of Concerned Scientists.
As the proposed deal fell apart in the plenary session, Turkish Environment Minister Murat Kurum, the president of COP31, was absent, leaving it to Elchin Allahverdiyev of Azerbaijan to announce the failure.
“Unfortunately, we were unable to reach agreement on a cover decision. And that's disappointing, very disappointing,” said Australia's Chris Bowen, COP31's president of negotiations.
Bowen said the Dubai explicit call to wean away from coal, oil and natural gas that cause climate change is still in force: “Transition away from fossil fuels in the real world is happening. It's happening. It's happening at speed and it's irreversible.”
Other climate issues weren't settled, and many were deferred to next year's negotiations in Ethiopia. They include details on transitioning away from fossil fuels, financial help for poorer nations to adapt to the warming world and action on gender and climate.
For this year's negotiations, Turkey made global electrification its signature issue. A proposal introduced separately from the main agreement calls for countries to increase the share of electricity in total final energy consumption from about 21 per cent today to 35 per cent by 2035. This would require nations to commit to measures such as switching transportation — including cars, trucks and planes — from fossil fuels to electricity and using electricity instead of coal to make industrial products. Nearly 100 nations signed up for this goal as part of the separate pledge.
In negotiations over the main agreement, the final proposal was distributed after 3 am and negotiators had little time to register their objections. Many observers and countries blamed the two-headed leadership of Turkey and Australia for the failure to reach an overarching agreement.
Speaking at the meeting, Antwi-Boasiako Amoah, chair of the African Group of Negotiators, said, “With all due respect, Mr. President, you have not shown respect to a group of 54 countries (from Africa) and my country (Ghana) for that matter.”
Confusion ensued at the meeting. Kurum was caught on a hot mic telling UN climate chief Simon Stiell “to sit down,” as Stiell tried to advise him on proceedings onstage.
Earlier this week, Panamanian Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro said the talks were being held hostage by a “petroleum mafia” and needed to be reformed.
Manuel Pulgar-Vidal, president of COP20 and now climate energy lead at the World Wildlife Fund, said “COP31 left too much undone.”
“Too many once again shied away from the toughest decisions, including how to turn their commitment to transition away from fossil fuels into real action," he said. "The climate will not wait for governments to find their courage.”
Earlier this year, the United Nations Environment Program announced that the world will blow past the Paris Agreement temperature threshold of limiting long-term warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) above preindustrial times. The goal should now be to limit how much the world exceeds that threshold and then somehow come back down using systems to suck carbon out of the air, U.N. officials said.
The world is heading for between 2.7 C and 3 C (between 4.9 F and 5.4 F) of warming by the end of the century, scientists estimate. October 2026 had the largest temperature increase above preindustrial temperatures of any month on record at 1.8 C (3.2 F), according to Berkeley Earth, which said there's a 97 per cent chance that 2026 will end up as the warmest year on record.