Putin praises summit result, calls Biden a tough negotiator

The two leaders concluded three hours of talks Wednesday at an opulent villa facing Lake Geneva by exchanging expressions of mutual respect but firmly restating their starkly different views on cyberattacks, the conflict in Ukraine, political dissent and other issues. At the same time, they announced an agreement to return each other's ambassadors and mapped more talks on arms control and cybersecurity.

Putin, who hailed Biden as a highly experienced and constructive interlocutor at a news conference in Geneva, offered more praise of the US leader on Thursday in a video call with graduates of a government management school.

Biden kept him on his guard with his savvy negotiating skills, Putin said.

“He perfectly knows the matter," Putin said. "He is fully concentrated and knows what he wants to achieve. And he does it very shrewdly.”He dismissed what he described as media attempts to cast Biden as physically frail, noting that the 78-year-old US president was in great shape even though the meeting wrapped up a European tour for him that included the G-7 and NATO summits.

“He was on a long trip, he flew in from across the ocean, involving jetlag,” the 68-year-old Putin said, adding that he knows how tiring travel can be.

“The atmosphere was quite friendly,” he added. “I think we managed to understand each other, we managed to understand each other''s positions on key issue, they differ on many things and we noted the differences. At the same time, we established areas and points where we can possibly bring our positions closer in the future.”Putin particularly emphasized the importance of an agreement to conduct dialogue on cybersecurity between experts, saying it would help reduce tensions.

Biden said he and Putin agreed to have their experts work out an understanding about what types of critical infrastructure would be off-limits to cyberattacks. The agreement follows a flood of ransomware attacks against U.S. businesses and government agencies that US officials said originated from Russia.

Putin, who has strongly denied any Russian state role in the cyberattacks, argued Thursday that “instead of finger-pointing and bickering, we should better combine efforts to fight cybercrime.”Putin''s spokesman Dmitry Peskov described the summit as positive and productive, saying it allowed the leaders "to directly put forward their positions and try to understand where interaction is possible and where there can be no interaction due to categorical disagreements.”Peskov particularly noted the joint statement from the presidents that said the two countries will conduct a dialogue on strategic stability issues and reaffirmed that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought” — a principle declared by U.S. President Ronald Reagan and Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev at their Geneva summit in 1985.

Restating the principle was a “significant achievement” amid current tensions between Moscow and Washington, said Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov, who attended the talks.

The strategic stability dialogue would cover a wide range of issues related to nuclear and other weapons and is key to reducing the risk of conflict between the two superpowers.

The talks follow a decision this year to extend the New START, the last remaining U.S.-Russian arms control pact and would be aimed at working out a follow-up agreement after it expires in 2026.

The negotiations will be complex and strenuous. The US is worried about new destabilizing weapons developed by Russia, such as the atomic-powered, nuclear-armed Poseidon underwater drone, while Russia wants to include US missile defense and potential space-based weapons in an agreement.

“It''s a difficult task to conjugate the approaches and formulas,” Ryabkov said. “But we are ready to try to solve it.”Konstantin Kosachev, a deputy speaker of Russia''s upper house of parliament, hoped that talks between experts would help reduce the bad blood.

“The more often experts will meet, the less room the politicians will have for speculation and manipulation,” he told The Associated Press.

The decision to return the ambassadors, who left their posts amid the tensions, was also widely billed by Russian officials and experts as an important move to stabilize ties.

Russia recalled its ambassador, Anatoly Antonov, for consultations in March after Biden described Putin as a killer in an interview. John Sullivan, the U.S. ambassador to Moscow, flew home in April after public suggestions from Russian officials that he should leave to mirror Antonov''s departure.

US-Russian ties have plummeted to all-time lows after Moscow's 2014 annexation of Ukraine's Crimean Peninsula, accusations of Russian interference in elections and cyberattacks, and Western criticism of the Kremlin''s crackdown on the opposition.

Biden criticized the imprisonment of Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny and other moves by the Kremlin to stifle dissent and independent media. Putin shot back, keeping to his practice of never mentioning his chief political foe by name, saying Navalny knew he was breaking the law and was duly punished. He added that government critics designated as “foreign agents” were pursuing malign Western interests.

In comments posted to his Instagram account, Navalny denounced Putin''s comments as lies.

“He just doesn''t say a word of truth,” Navalny said. “Clearly, he just physically can''t stop lying.”

Navalny was arrested in January upon returning from Germany, where he spent five months recovering from a nerve agent poisoning that he blames on the Kremlin — an accusation that Russian officials reject. In February, Navalny was given a 2 1/2-year prison term for violating the terms of a suspended sentence from a 2014 embezzlement conviction that he dismissed as politically motivated.

Navalny''s supporters held a protest in Geneva ahead of Putin''s visit and dotted the city with billboards blasting the Kremlin for refusing to investigate his poisoning.

On Ukraine, Russia reaffirmed its view that the country''s bid for NATO membership represents a red line, while the US has restated that the alliance''s doors remain open for its membership.

Some in Ukraine voiced hope the summit could help ease tensions that spiked this year when Russia bolstered its forces near Ukraine.

“Reducing the conflict potential in U.S.-Russian relations could help lower tensions on our border with Russia,” said Volodymyr Fesenko, head of the Penta Center think tank.

But independent Kyiv-based political expert Vadim Karasev warned of a danger that the lack of resolution of the conflict with Russia-backed separatists in Ukraine''s eastern industrial heartland known as the Donbas would make it frozen, and the country would steadily drift to the fringes of international politics.

“The results of the Putin-Biden meeting will cool Kyiv''s aspirations,” Karasev said. “Ukraine won''t be able to quickly join NATO, and the conflict in Donbas will become a chronic one. The Ukrainian issue will lose its acuteness, leaving Kyiv on the periphery of the global agenda.”Experts say that sharp differences rule out any quick progress on the divisive issues.

“Confrontation will continue, but there is a hope now that instead of being uncontrollable it could become more orderly,” said Valery Garbuzov, the head of the US and Canada Institute, the government-funded think-tank.